S30v vs s35vn reddit Most upvoted wins. It has more edge retention, corrosion resistance, ease of sharpening, and about the same toughness. It sharpens easier and is cheaper while still having a pretty great edge retention. When choosing between D2 and S30V steel, remember that both materials have their unique characteristics. S30v is still a perfectly acceptable steel on knives within the premium price point. The larger carbides will typically hold an edge longer, but that comes at the cost of less edge stability at extreme angles, lower toughness, harder sharpening, and less “absolute sharpness potential”. Not sure we S35VN is way ahead of 1095 in everyway, besides ease of sharpening and cost. Although S45VN improves on the corrosion resistance and edge retention properties of S35VN, it may lack some of the toughness that S35VN is known for. Basically to my knowledge the only company that does it right is Spyderco at 62HRC. On like for like blades S30V, 3V and even A2 is going to outlast and stay sharp longer 420HC by a large margin. Also looking to do a few other things as well. Personally I haven't seen anyone really talking about their S30v. This difference is reflected in S35VN steel’s name, as the additional ‘5’ and ‘N’ represent How S35VN and S30V Are Made. S30V, also called CPM S30V, is a high-end S45VN has a higher content of chromium carbide compared with S35VN and S30V, with equivalent MC to S35VN but lower than S30V. However, MagnaCut stainless steel surprisingly demonstrated even better corrosion resistance than S30V, despite having lower chromium content. Locked post. I also carry a shiro neon if I'm feeling fancy. Last edited: May 6, 2017 这个举动将s35vn与s30v等许多钢材彻底区分开来，铌和碳组合在一起，使s35vn更硬，至少比s30v硬15-20％。 碳是钢材中最重要的元素，对钢材的硬度起着至关重要的作用，碳含量越高，刀也就会越硬。 Most members don’t have an S35vn Esee yet to make this a good vote. I still havent found a sharpening protocol that makes this steel perform well on wood, but I have for S30v and gasp ZDP189 which should be hilariously garbage. The resulting steel is expected to have similar hardness and corrosion resistance to S30V and Sure, but you were asking about Niolox vs S35VN. N690 vs M390: Another high-end PM I know they say MC is more or less on pair with S35VN in edge retention. I’ve found S35VN less It's in the realm of S30V/S45VN/S35VN in my experience. The few dedicated knife steels, such as 14C28N and S35VN, have very good reputations for a reason. One is just a little newer. It has a similar composition. Perhaps the changes would boost the performance folks would see anecdotally in real world use. S35vn tends to be abit tougher and easier to sharpen. As to Buck's 420HC performing as well as S30VIn the test Buck posted they clearly note the edge profile of the blade is what gave their knife the advantage vs the thicker blade it was tested against. While it is more difficult to grind than a simple non alloyed steel such as 1095, 80crv2, AEB L, or 52100, it is easier to grind than many of the higher HRC, larger grain, higher vanadium steels that are very common in the knife world today such as S30V, M390, M4, even S45VN. 0 for 14C28N, 6. I wouldn’t mind having a 110 like the September BOTM in S35vn. Ikr! I have a 940-1 which literally gives the steel the best chance of not chipping because it’s such a thick blade and is a fairly steep bevel and the thing will chip if I hit one of those fucking copper staples you sometimes get on cardboard It tends to be similar to CPM S35VN and better than steels like 154CM. 327K subscribers in the knives community. Feb 3, 2023 #3 There are some Made in China (not Taiwan) knives (non-cooking) stating S35VN. S90V offers better edge retention than S30V because it contains more Carbon and Vanadium in its composition. Or check it out in the app stores so im wondering what the pros and cons of each. I'm curious how Nitro-V steel compares and contrasts to the following steels: CTS-XHP CPM 154 N690 S45vn takes a very aggressive edge at 600 grit and holds it very well. Though it’s edge breakdown is very similar to s30v and s35vn, just better. Terms & Policies S45vn is an improvement over S35vn, which is the descendent of s30v. S35VN is slight upgrade to that, having added Niobium, which improves toughness, strength, and corrosion resistance slightly. There's a lot of hype around Magnacut and while I am not after for top of the line edge retention, if the difference is like between Aus8 and S35VN ++ I would definitely wait. In my experience the lower toughness has S35VN, 14C28N, and AEB-L are easier to heat treat and can reach higher hardness levels (63+) if that is desired over the higher corrosion resistance. In the patent of K490 [7], they measured the toughness both with and without a S35vn Vs. Reply More posts from r/knives. L. Slightly more stain resistant than S30V too. Take a look and let that sink in a little bit. But, as we saw in testing, the latter can hold an edge longer — by 8%, to be precise. 6” drop point plain edge blade, made from the CTS XHP that offers great hardness, high corrosion resistance and it will hold an edge forever, the knife comes with a light, and strong carbon fibre handle, a mid-positioned back You won't mind supporting their innovation by paying $40 bucks more then BD1N LW or the regular G10 S30V Para 3. M4 is a tool steel, S30V was designed as a great all around knife steel. I have custom knives, high end commercial knives, all different steels, but I have a couple Buck knives made from the 420hc, and they just take a wicked edge, they really sharpen up S30V holds a working edge for a good while, and is not difficult to sharpen, altho not as easy to sharpen as 1095. S35VN. Like, you are not going to cut the same thing with 3 knives in 3 steels and after a two weeks you are going to N690 and S30V are similar in many aspects, but S30V has an edge in terms of toughness and wear resistance thanks to the PM process. However, MagnaCut steel, M390 steel, 20CV steel, S35VN, and S45VN are closely related and may offer better performance than S30V steel when Nitro-V steel vs S30V. XHP is great. In knife steel nerds testing, toughness was the same, edge retention was slightly reduced and corrosion resistance was slightly increased with s45vn. Controversial. Because it contains 0. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS Manix 2 w/ G10, combo edge, S30V Delica 4 w/ FRN, combo edge, VG-10 Tenacious w/ G10, combo edge, 8Cr13MoV (coated) XHP is basically S35VN from a different manufacturer. The 14c28n steel is basically an entry level steel used by Kershaw (Think Chive, Scallion, Leek) althought the Compare those to edge retentions such as 3. People make it seem like S30V is much less tough than S35VN but i have found little performance difference between the two (provided good heat treat). 14C28N VS S30V? I’m looking to finally replace my long lost serrated DLC Avalanche with a Tanto serrated Blur, when I had a friend mention the griptillian. I am not saying there is no difference at all, but in reality, it is not going to be night and day difference. Agreed I feel like it performs like S30V and sharpens like it I'm not turning my nose up at it, simply baffled by people acting like it's fucking incredible. S35VN vs. Reeves wanted it as something that users could take to a lot of places and not get rust due to mud and crap getting in the knife. Buck has produced millions of knives with the 420hc, and it is great for hunting. ) simply lack the toughness and edge stability necessary to keep a keen My Native is in S35VN and I love it. 14C28N vs. LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Share Link. Spyderco PM2 S30V Benchmade Griptillain 550-1 20CV Spyderco pm2 s35vn Microtech Ultratech 2 and 3 each stay in a uniform. These are very minor differences by the numbers but are significant in the rockwell scale. 0 for S30V, and 9. Hard to go wrong with any Spyderco IMHO -- I have several, Military in S110V, GB2 in M4, Native 5 in S35VN, PM2 in S30V. He set in motion a process and a philosophy about usability with blade steels. S35VN is the evolution of S30V. S35VN is a great steel, but it Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I gave my Royal to my daughter because I already have the better version of the Royal with S35VN steel blade in the deep purple. The composition is VERY similar to those, but it has more free carbides. kobold. My understanding is that compared to s30v, S35vn has niobium in place of some of the 3V is by far my absolute favorite steel, its just so tough, and it always seems to hold an edge nearly as good as S30V/S35VN. S45VN will be just that much tougher. Reactions: NG VI and kobold. In the realm of super steels, two names stand tall: S35VN and S30V. For example, the standard Manix 2 with S30V (the G10 model at that) is around $138 but the Manix 2 LW in FRCP with SPY27 is $154 in late 2022. " The CATRA numbers published by Crucible are: 145 - S30V 143 - S45VN 140 - S35VN In-Depth Look at S30V. S35vn and S30v are developed to follow the exact same protocols. Thread starter Ocelot85; Start date Jun 11, 2019; Which stainless would you choose or prefer for a 4 inch EDC blade? My understanding is that the purpose of S356VN was to get the abrasion resistance of S30V but with more toughness. S35VN exhibits superior transverse toughness compared to S30V, with a Charpy C-notch impact energy of 12 ft-lbs versus 10 ft-lbs for S30V. My favorite at the moment is K390. They have slightly different percentages of different elements. Been eyeing a 110/112 auto for a while now and have almost bought one several times now but for not a whole lot more you can upgrade from their 420hc, which is really good steel with their BOS heat-treat, to their S30v. Larrin rates the corrosion resistance at 7. S30V, S35VN, M390, 20CV, D2, S110V, annndd Titanium etc. I don't know if CRK has said that S35VN is any better, and that's why I am hoping for real-world testing and experience. An excellent balance if you are looking for a rust proof steel with better edge performance than pe H1. There will be NO respectful disagreement. But as you already mentioned its semi stainless not fully stainless. CPM Cruwear would be a great middle ground, as would 4v. S35VN and S30V are both made through the same process: The CPM, or Crucible Particle Metal, process designed by Crucible Industries, a New York-based steel manufacturer. LC200N vs S30V Share Add a Comment. KenHash. Knife Specific Discussion. S35VN and the new S45VN. It’s tougher than S30V and has 01026029D started a thread S35VN steel vs N690 Co Stainless Steel in General Knife Discussion advantages and disadvantages? see more 8 replies | 219 view(s) 01026029D's Avatar (Twitter) LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Share Link. Knifemakers reported that MagnaCut Lately I’ve been watching and hunting for something different in steel under $100 , and have gotten some S35vn, 20cv, V-toku2,vg10,bd1n, everything but S30v, and I have to say each one has a unique feeling, when sharpened the exact same, DMT 600 ,then stropping with progressive diamond spray microns, IMO unless you really like spending time So get it in S35VN for $105 Reply reply Holiday-Ad4806 • At that point you might as well get a knife with a compression lock like the Para 3 lightweight in BD1N for $120, or a Delica with a better feel in hand and a solid lockback like I said in my other post for around $80 This is Reddit. This new steel is more incremental in its benefits and not a substantial change over S35VN. Apart from the properties, you must consider their price and how It's similar in composition to VG10 if that helps you any. K390, I haven't sharpened it enough to rule out edge fatigue from the factory belt. So take s30v vs vg-10 toughness tests with a grain of salt. But the cynic in me sees it as mostly a marketing ploy. Lucabrasi Member Posts: 107 Joined S35VN 于 2009 年由美国粉末冶金公司 Crucible Industries 推出，作为其 CPM 不锈钢系列的一部分。 它是对 S30V 钢的改进，具有增强的机械加工性和韧性。 瑞典钢铁生产商山特维克于 2011 年推出的 14C28N 也旨在提 它是s30v的改良版，通过增加钼和钴的含量，提高了强度和耐磨性，同时保持了s30v的优秀的耐锈性。s35vn刀片的硬度达到了58-61 hrc，拥有优秀的切割表现和锋利度，能够承受重负荷和大量使用。 此外，s35vn材质的刀片能够在各种环境下保持卓越的性能，不会因为 Final thoughts on SPY27 vs S45VN Steel. It offers good wear resistance and can hold an edge for a long time, but its high hardness can make it brittle and I always heard the chipping issue but I never experience one my self. M390 vs. Large fixed blade- s35vn vs 3v. Henry_P Member Posts: 275 Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2020 5:54 pm IME, S30V is an excellent all-arounder for normal folders, maybe my The fact that Crucible has come out with two "updated" generations since S30V was released in 2001 (i. D2 and 440C are fine imo. S35VN achieved 12 ft-lbs. Even though those are more expensive steels and might make you feel better about paying $200 for a knife, in the end they may not be the right steels for the job. While it's wear resistance is slightly less than S30V, when the edge is maintained like most of us do, and non abrasive materials are cut, like most of us cut, SPY Stain Resistance is better on MagnaCut, MagnaCut destroys M390 in toughness even more than S35VN does we are talking about; 9ft-ibs for M390 @62HRC 25ft-ibs for S35VN @61HRC 38ft-ibs for MagnaCut @62,5HRC (Longitudinal toughness, Charpy C notch values from 1/4 unnotched specimens) 5ft-ibs for M390 @61,5HRC 10ft-ibs for S35VN @61HRC These are all better than budget steels. I'm looking at replacing my RAT 2 with a RAT 1, and there's a 60-70$ difference between the two steels. I decided to examine this at the level of all We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I dunno- I like the Cutlery Shop Shaman for the Orange and black colorway a lot, and the fact that it has a solid steel is great! If it were S35VN I'd feel no different I'm new to this particular Reddit community and I'm looking into a new knife that happens to have a Nitro-V blade. These two are "nearly stainless", similar wear resistance to s35vn, and are more tough. Initial hair whittling sharpness off a strop is gone after cutting whatever it is you're cutting with it, but it'll obviously hold a working edge for a good while. Reply reply More posts you may like r/knives I also have extensive experience with powder steels (M4, 1V, 3V, 4V, A2, D2, 20V, S35VN, S30V, Elmax, M390, to name a few) outside the kitchen. How much better is s35vn? I have both a kizer cormorant and a kizer hiccup. I generally like S30V/S35VN/S90V. It is difficult to find steels that will beat S30V in all performance aspects. He was instrumental in developing S30V and S35VN with CPM. Pretty sure there might have been a Look at S30V steel for a baseline of basic premium steel. S35VN and S30V are however slightly better in edge retention than SPY27 but it is easier to get an edge on SPY27 over S30V and S35VN. s35vn will also bend more before broken than m390, it will also react better to impact because of softness. According to the chemical composition and the HRC of the steel, the CPM s90v Steel has the following features: CPM s90v Edge Retention: With a high presence of vanadium and carbon, s90v steel offers extreme edge retention (might be Great EDC steels (IMO) because they're pretty easy to resharpen if you ding them on something or accidentally hit the knife on concrete or whatnot are S30V, S35VN, 154cm, CPM 154, CTS-XHP, Elmax, AEB-L/440C, N690Co, M4 (super D2 basically), and D2 (as long as you're mindful that it is higher carbon and can rust). I was told s30v was inferior the other day for God sakes really? I actually use my knives and s30v is actually still pretty affordable to actually use. S35VN is one of the new-fangled super steels and is popular on newer outdoor knives since it is tougher than another supersteel, S30V, and a touch easier to sharpen with comparable edge retention. L: Benchmade Bugout R: Cold Steel Recon 1. e. Business, Economics, and Finance. Sure, you can find other steels that hold a better edge or have better toughness but you may give up corrosion resistance (CPM-M4?). The key difference in All are very similiar in my experience, S30V is a little tougher than 154cm, and will hold an edge slightly longer than both, but the trade off is it will also be slightly more difficult to sharpen, between 154cm and VG-10 almost no difference really, VG-10 might hold an edge like 2% longer, but the blade grind/edge will make way more of a difference, so in actual use, It has really good corrosion resistance for a non stainless high performance steel as well though the S30V/S35Vn will usually better it. If your main priority is a knife that does not require frequent sharpening, go for Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Or check it out in the app stores Home It’s my first knife with a CTS XHP blade and I just use it as my S30V, S35VN, M390 ones and I never had any corrosion problem with those. Question Ive been very interested in sg2 but Ive only found things saying that its comparable to s30v and has similar makeup to vg10 S35VN beats S30V, but S30V beats S35VN in carboard cuts. Properties Nitro V Steel S30V Steel; Toughness: 7. M390 etc. S30v done by benchmade is likely going to perform better than s35vn done by civivi anyway. About S30V SteelAbout S35VN SteelS30V vs S35VN: Comparison TableToughnessEdge RetentionCorrosion ResistanceEase Of SharpeningIntention Of UsePriceIs S35VN Better Than S30V?Final Thoughts A Reddit space where people can come together to show and discuss their various EDC items, ask questions and receive advice from fellow carriers, and generally promote the enjoyment of EDC. S30V vs S90V Edge retention. It seems very corrosion resistant and the edge is holding up well to light/medium use. 2HRC. S35VN steel is considered to be tougher and is, therefore, better suited for larger knives such as hunting, tactical, and survival knives. SPY27 vs CTS BD1N. Little more edge retention, but a little less edge stability (which is fixed with a micro bevel). Don't know the differences between the two. CRK has always run their steel a little softer in comparison to other companies, If you have a choice between S30V and S35VN, which one are you choosing? I found some interesting results about these 2 steels in my cut testing. As a premium blade . But I 这一切始于S30V。在2001年S30V问世之前，大多数用于刀具的高性能钢材最初是为其他用途设计的，并被刀具制造商用于刀具制作。而S30V则是由钢铁制造商Crucible Industries与领先的刀具制造商合作开发，专门用于高端口袋刀。他们希望打造一种易于热处理、平衡适用于广泛应用，并且在相应价格点上比 CPM-154 VS CPM-S35VN. That improved toughness is likely due to a refined carbide structure. There are many better steels overall and many that are far superior in specific/singular attributes, but in a general purpose knife you’ll never go wrong with S30V. M390 approximately 8 ft-lbs. Hardness is a vital aspect of knife steel as it directly impacts edge retention and wear resistance. S30V is a more carbide heavy steel making it more wear resistant than 14C28N and has better corrosion resistance. 5: 4: Edge Retention: 3: 6: Corrosion Resistance: 7: 7. K. But if you’re here, you’re probably wondering what the differences are and which one is better. S35VN is may look superior to S30V on paper. Price. M4 will probably develop a patina over a long time as it's not a stainless steel while you don't really have to worry about S30V. They’re almost identical in composition (S30V contains 1. 154CM vs. These high-performance stainless steels have become popular choices for blades in the knife-making community, but which one reigns supreme? In this highly anticipated battle, we will compare the key characteristics and performance of Posted by u/TheBraBandit - 5 votes and 20 comments I prefer having multiple knives with decent steel like S35VN or VG10 . The main poster stated it was the best stainless steel yet, in his experience. Poor edge retention and doesn't take a fine edge. I know that some people have difficulty sharpening s30v but I don’t and they stay plenty sharp for a long time. In a few years they will and will love the steel. S30V and S35VN are nearly equally matched. 22 votes, 13 comments. S45VN achieved 11 ft-lbs. Congratulations! This post qualifies you for the free knife giveaway ending on the 29th of Feb. That said, I really want one in SPY27 too. It's a budget steel since there are plenty of sub-$65 options with it. If s30v generally has higher edge retention and lower toughness when compared to s35vn, but s35vn is easier to work with when manufacturering and is a little easier to heat treat consistently. It shows the high corrosion resistance and much of the toughness of H1 while being much closer (than H1) to steels like s30v in wear resistance. 1095 in the hands of a skilled maker will i'm sure produce a good knife, but there are many, many steels that have much more desirable characteristics. Going to say again, I think most knife users will be hard pressed to notice a difference between S30V, S35VN and S45VN. For less than a 10% decrease in edge retention compared to D2 vs S30V – Complete Comparison Hardness. What is your go-to blade steel? D2, CPM-20CV, S35VN, 1095, 440, or any of the dozens of other metals put there, which one do you choose to carry? If you have different choices for different functions, tell me about it! EDC Even if you want something tougher than s35vn, there are incremental steps between there and 3v that have more edge holding and more stainlessness than 3v does but less than s35vn. A few steels that are often considered superior to S30V include S35VN, M390, CPM-20CV, and CTS-XHP. The major problem with M390 is that it is rarely heat treated to it’s full potential. Sort by: Best. 4V beats S35VN in thoughness not directly edge retention. Oh my gosh what an amazing knife for a budget blade! Final Comparison: D2 vs S30V. Xenforo Default Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. Makers simply test what the industry produces and find the best steels suited to knife making. The former is in S35vn and the later 154cm. My point being. Need advice, am big noob! :| I was wondering if this drill press would work well enough to drill holes in those metals. As a reward for his interest and feedback on the product Chris was the first maker who had access to commercial S35VN around 200. Honestly, if you’ve already got an Inkosi in S35VN, I can’t see a practical reason why you’d switch just after new steel is available. The main purpose of this article is to indicate the extent to which S30V and S35VN knives have penetrated the commercial knife market. 5% cobalt addition. General Knife Discussion. I’ve heard mixed feedback on comparing s30v and S35vn but most say they are very close only the S35vn takes a finer edge. I have a few knives having a s35vn, s90v and s30v. However there are other Unless you really like the color of the handles the S30V one comes with (seems to be either pink or green zome, from what google image search tells me), I'd look for something better than S30V. I fairly sure both were manufactured in China. Like 154CM, there is a newer version, S35VN, which shares many of the same attributes as S30V but is easier to craft into a knife thanks to niobium. So we expect better edge retention than S35VN but where it sits compared to S30V A beautiful gem, lightweight, powerful, beautiful design, a Must-have, the Chaparral by Spyderco is a high-end knife that you will definitely enjoy, it has a 3. S30v/s35vn is a very happy medium in my daily use. In your opinion which do you prefer and why. Open comment sort options but I had an s30v blade from them that I was constantly chipping where a Benchmade in the Companies have to heat treat their steels, and different companies do a better/worse jobs than one another. So it's probably a decent knife steel. Expand user menu Open settings I am wondering is a cold steel or pre-pandemic ontario aus 8 blade actually better than a Kizer/Civivi 154cm or s35vn? Share Sort by: Best. For me, it'll never perform better than s90v or m390/20cv. For instance, S35VN will be a little tougher than S30V, and will keep an edge longer. It beat S35VN in testing by 8. To choose the right knife between S45VN and S30V, you must consider if the properties of each match your knife needs and lifestyle. 0 for S90V. Hence a logical choice with S45VN. Spy27 steel and CTS BD1N offer very close The s30v is a "superior steel," but don't let that scare you away from the 420hc. S35VN steel is considered to be tougher and is, therefore, better suited for larger knives such as S35VN exhibits superior transverse toughness compared to S30V, with a Charpy C-notch impact energy of 12 ft-lbs versus 10 ft-lbs for S30V. Xenforo Default Style Contact us; Terms and We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. S30v is great. Reactions: Dergyll. Specifically, S35VN steel is typically 15-20% tougher than S30V steel and has slightly better edge retention. Thread starter FlyingDutchman; Start date May 8, 2021; 1; 2; Next. edge retention can compete with high-end steels like S30V family steels, M390, Elmax or even K390. It might be hard for folks to answer this question because you mainly notice the difference when you compare a powder steel to All depends on your use requirements for the knife. Platinum To get its own steel formula and persuade Crucible to make a commitment to a new steel, Spyderco must plan to use a lot of it. 75% vanadium. S30v might have the potential to have abit more wear resistance from abrasion resistance. S90V has a better edge retention but let's all be honest, edge retention for most of us is just numbers on a piece of paper. They are both made in japan. Thanks . Both steels are byproducts of metallurgy powder. Edge retention vs toughness, stainless vs possibility of patina/rust. 9/10, while s30v scores 7. 6/10. I greatly prefer s35vn over s30v. Hit it with the strop again and it'll be back to hair whittling Toughness vs Edge Retention. Easier than S30V I'd say, not that S30V is hard to sharpen. There have been rumors to the effect that the only reason for the change is lower costs due to less machining, polishing, and such to bring it to the same standards as S30V. The Battle of Super Steels: S35VN vs S30V. S35VN can be used for pretty much any It could also be S30V. Magnacut vs S35VN - Discussion Thread . S35VN Steel S35VN, first created in 2009, modified the In partnership with Crucible Industries, a steel producer based in New York, Chris Reeve developed the S35VN and S30V steels using a specialized technique known as Crucible Particle Metal (CPM) technology. Old. Expand user menu Open settings menu. It shows a better overall set of properties, I think, making S45VN a good upgrade to either S30V or S35VN. S30V steel, on the other hand, is more S30V, S35VN, and S45VN are all similar. Or check it out in the app stores Home; Popular; TOPICS. 5 HRC and most production M4 is run 63-64 HRC. Gaming. It was nice to see in the Pm2 S45vn that it was run slightly harder than the Para 3 S30v. There’s slight variation between the two but in practical use they’re the same. It's easy to sharpen and very stain resistant. **The first rule of KnifeClub** is to talk about KnifeClub! Bring a friend! This S30V vs S45VN – Complete Comparison Hardness. My favourite edc now is an XHP blade that sharpens easily, is tough, and holds a good edge. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It also really depends on what it is you are looking At A GlanceIn a head-to-head comparison between 154CM and S30V knife steels, both options offer advantages and disadvantages depending on the user's needs. The ultimate knife idiots on Reddit are the ones that try to strip live wires with their knives and end up blowing up the knife From what I've seen the premium steels (S35VN, M390 for example) on Kizers, TwoSuns, GTs, KJs (and many others) show about the same hardness or maybe 1 point below some US made knives and about 1-2 points below Spyderco (king of production HT?). If you want stainless but also toughness, you’re probably not gonna want S30V or M390. I want to be able to add my own S30V and S35VN knives on the commercial market. , S35VN and S45VN) suggest it's getting a little long in the tooth. Some people claim that s35vn has only extremely slightly less abrasion resistance than s30v. S35VN steel is an improvement of S30V steel and offers improved toughness and edge stability compared to S30V. Which is probably what you want from a smaller knife like a Para 3 - small enough to carry all the time and a good fit for any situation. ARKnife S35VN steel with snakewood and custom leather. The large difference is that M4 has a ton of tungsten and molybdenum so it's harder and tougher than S30V at the expense of corrosion resistance. I find S30V to be a great balance and easy to sharpen and take care of. From what I read, however, S35VN clearly rated better than S30V. but edge retention will be in the same ballpark of S30V, so if edge retention is what you are after there are better choices. S45vn is an update to the metal composition of s35vn, which was an update to s30v. These steels generally In my opinion S90V is a great steel but S30V is also. Secondly, the law of diminishing returns starts to really kick into high gear around the vg-10/s30v level (imo). Developed by Crucible Industries, both steels are popular choices due to their excellent balance of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion Knives with S30V and S35VN blades have proven popular in the medium and premium-priced knife markets. S35VN is supposed to hold a hair splitting sharp edge for longer than S30V. Although more thoughness also impacts how long yor edge will last. The bur forms on one side immediately. The main difference between S30V and S35VN steel is their toughness. Discuss Spyderco's products and history. Toughness. Don't be fooled by 'CPM'—it's not five better than S30V, which is a great CPM-S30V is great steel, it has become the staple material used in several knives (Spyderco, Benchmade, ZT). It is slightly better at retaining an edge than S35VN, but it is as expensive as M390. We have steels with more Vs and Ns now so they're all no good anymore. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS for reference S35VN does 180 feet, M390 300 feet, K390 800 feet, 14C28N 150 feet. It will be easier to sharpen than S30V, but S30V will hold an edge longer. If you are open to any steel, MagnaCut would be better than any of the mentioned ones as a general purpose knife steel. with different steels over the years keeps showing me that high carbide steels (D2, S30V, M390, ZDP 189, etc. S35vn fixed the chippy nature of s30v (why it gets silly Folks get caught up in a peeing contest on these super steels. M390, CPM 20CV, or CTS-204p, for example. S30V. S30v and s35vn are fractions of a point away from each other in their stats when heat treated similarly. M390 - 3,5 out of 10 S45VN - 4,5 out of 10 Measured as lateral force pressure. The point is the edge retention for this and similar steels was rated super low, so you'd think: easy to dull, easy to sharpen, but hard to break, with It's a bit over my head but SPY27 sounds like it's pretty close to S30V/S35VN. An alternative to r/knives. Good luck! Won't the S45vn steel be harder to sharpen at 61 vs the 59 hardness of the S35vn? Is it my imagination or do supersteels feel more brittle compared to the more forgiving "give" of a normal steel? I have a Sebenza in S30V that I’ve used for years and the blade is still in top shape. r/knives • by AlphaSlicer. M390 - 3,5 out of 10 S35VN - 5 out of 10 Measured as lateral force pressure. i saw the native 5 and i really like the G-10 but have no experience with S35VN. read the above comments. By comparison s30v and s35vn as well as the 154s are relatively quite course grained. Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn Reddit D2 and S35VN (or CPM-S35VN--it’s the same thing) are both pretty good quality steels. Alternatives S90V vs S30V: CPM S30V provides better toughness and wear resistance but lags behind S90V in edge retention and grindability. It equates to just slightly different characteristics in how the steel performs. Some people said S35VN is better, improved version for this steel but actually according to Bohler's CATRA and toughness test; S30V did outperform S35VN at both aspect. Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Share Link Hence, to pinpoint its strengths and weaknesses, we'll compare 14C28N steel with other acclaimed steels, including S30V, S35VN, and M390 Superclean. 5: Nitro V Steel vs S30V. bax229. The cormorant seems to cut slightly better, but I mostly attribute that to its hollow grind. However it's worth noting almost all production s30v is run at 59-60. The answer is yes, but only slightly. Given the results from laboratory testing, S45VN seems like an incremental upgrade from both S30V and S35VN. 05% more carbon and 1% more vanadium, S30V provides slightly better edge retention. It is best known for its ability to be good at just about anything. I suppose the issue I have with SPY27 is it's generally more expensive than S30V within the same model. I was just about to get Its almost the same. I wonder if this actually S35VN from Crucible or the equivalent 14Cr14Mov being used. Well, here’s the short version: CPM-S35VN is better than D2. Having 2 knives in the field is an added security . (Twitter) LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Share Link. Reactions: NorWest_05. They’re well rounded steels. Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The vanadium is supposed to help keep the grain size down, so it should be easier to HT in a forge. 45% carbon; 14% chromium; 2% molybdenum; 4% 我们在看折刀时，能注意到，现在越来越多的折刀用s30v和s35vn钢。 这俩货的名字差不多，里面的结构构成也差不多。 像碳含量和铬含量，这俩含有的量就一样。 而且经过测试后，他俩的耐腐蚀性和刀刃锋利度保持性也一 Definitely hate seeing little spots though which my s35vn and 20cv knives don’t exhibit. I prefer s45vn to s30v, but only because s45vn is significantly more stainless than s30v. Also, M390 is supposed to be the same as 20CV, but 20CV outperforms M390 in cut tests on cardboard, I can't speak to CATRA and sisal tests compared to other steels, but for cardboard, the rules seem to change and that's what I care about for my job. And I suppose they have some reason to see it as an improvement over S30V/S35VN. If you’re a one-knife guy, you won’t 3v has a fine grain pattern, low HRC in the 58-60 HRC range and 2. I got caught up in the super steel thing and picked up the "amazing m390!" Where it excels is corrosion resistance while giving the properties of s30v. Or slightly reduced toughness relative to S35VN but with improved corrosion resistance and edge retention. New. Just like S35VN, S30V forms hard carbides that give it an all Here's a funny story: When S30V was brand new, Zero Tolerance and edgelord Mick Strider made a $300 S30V AR-type bayonet. The CRK quality and fit are what makes the knife great in They’re all good and nowadays I consider the design of the knife much more than if it has S35VN vs. Ease of Sharpening. While matching S35VN in edge retention, MagnaCut exceeds it in other areas. All steels benefit from that. The finish means a lot in that respect. Whilst there’s a noticeable difference in quality between the S30v and the 420HC, both will ultimately do a good job. 1 of 2 I believe the SV35N is a slight upgrade to the s30v so the Argali is still in the running. Edge retention between s30v and s45vn seems similar, but I've had s30v rust in my pocket while s45vn has proven to be m390-level stainless. While D2 provides good hardness and wear resistance, it lacks the toughness of S30V. There's something magical about that insane carbon S45VN VS S30V. These two steels share a close relationship, with S45VN being an evolution in Crucible’s line of advanced CPM stainless steels, building upon the success of the earlier S30V and S35VN. But with MC at 63-64 HRC and S35VN at 59-60 HRC are they still the same in that Knife Exchange. S30V only has 14% chromium but a ton of other stuff like vanadium which will be used for Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. 193K subscribers in the knifeclub community. S30V vs. Or check it out in the app stores   The average cost of a custom S30V 110 looks to be around 120 to 130 USD. Semi city k390 mid 65 vs Boulder mid 63 k390 is a great example of what a difference of 2 points is. I might call a modern take on a buck 110 the cold This helps hard-use blades such as an S30V bowie knife retain their edge and resist corrosion. Toughness: D2 torture test I’ll be fine tuning my kitchen knives (Misen & ZWILLING PRO) as well as my EDC knives (S30V, S35VN, S45VN, CM154) Locked post. S35VN is a premium grade stainless steel, 1095 is a lower midrange carbon steel. Valheim; Genshin Impact; Minecraft; Spydercos s30v and s35vn have never been tested above 59 hrc and cts-xhp have been tested regularly at 60-62 Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I would argue that S30V is better for every practical need. Its well balanced and has more wear resistance than s35vn, s45vn, cruwear, or magnacut, among many others. Once I had the hiccup professionally sharpened, it cuts like a lazer beam. The good mid tier steels are S45VN, LC200N, 20CV, and 204p. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; Trying to decide between S30v and CruWear. The issue is with s30vn vs s45vn and stuff like that. As a hunter I do have an My least favorite budget steel is CPM-S35VN. Not that S35 is bad, but I prefer more edge holding and don’t mind if the blade steel is a little chippy. Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. I would love to know what are your guy's favorite steel(s) and why? Me personally i love steels that can take any edge you want to put on it (such as K390 and 14c28n). Terms & Policies I agree about S30V vs S35VN. I have S35vn, s30v, 8c13mov, 9 something mov, 420c, buck 420c, 440c, 440a, cold steel Elmax is like M390 but tougher and easier to sharpen. S45VN and SPY27 represent two excellent stainless steel choices for knife makers and users demanding high hardness, edge retention, corrosion resistance and wear 3、CPM S35VN . At the same hardness, s30v has a better catra edge retention score just barely, by about 10 TCC. S30v: Specifications Steel Type. Real, good Italian and or American D2 is also really impressive, much better than the chinese stuff that The main difference between S30V and S35VN steel is their toughness. From that came the origional CPM S30V as well as the later CPM S35VN. 173K subscribers in the knifeclub community. S110V - VERY good water resistant and BEST EDGE RETENTION while still being stainless. . Now, I'm asking about this steel because I bought a 2018 Chris Reeve with s35vn, I do understand they heat treated on the softer side however. it reminds me of s30v, s35vn, etc. LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Other old stuff that we shouldn't use anymore includes S30V, S35VN, XHP, elmax. Sharpens very easily and responds to stropping very very well. Reactions: Vinton, Ianwold Steels like aus8, vg10, H1, 154cm, s30v and S35vn I have loved, still love and prefer over stuff like m390/20cv/204p, and the new tool steels. M390 is like a step up from S30V, takes slightly more strokes to sharpen but it also stays sharp longer. 27 posts 1; 2; Next; Chapparel FRN cts xhp; Southard 204p; Kapara s30v; Ikuchi s30v; Spydiechef lc200n, Waterway Lc200n; Manix 2 LW 20cv Past Spyderco: Endura zdp; Manix 2 LW s110v; Paramilitary 2 s30v. Manufacturer's Forums. S110V was developed to push those boundaries Then later on I got into that price point but CRK was using S30V and S35VN at RC 58-59 when most everyone else had upgraded at that price point. 2 points in this scales is alot. Spyderco. This is a pattern that I'm going to reproduce so I need a good model name for Nitro V is AEB-L with added nitrogen and vanadium. This is meant to be my primary EDC blade, and as much as I do work outdoors, I will probably cut some vines with it and maybe do some minor whittling or shaving of wood pieces I'm working on, but those will (probably) be the toughest obstacle the knife faces. It basically makes S35VN is a very well-rounded steel that is good for a wide variety of tasks and is a steel that is made almost exclusively for knives. M390 isn’t all that bad to sharpen though, so I wouldn’t let this be the deciding factor. While I am sure I would be oblivious and happy with LC200N, it is not a cheap knife and I don't want to be disappointed and having regrets once I find out LC200N might Both the Benchmade Bugout S30V and Spyderco Lil Native S30V give me a test result of about 150 feet, every time. What it does have is about 4 times the toughness of s30v so no chipping which is a problem with s30v, way better corrosion resistance, finer grain structure which results in more edge stability so sharpens easier and S30V has a toughness of 6 ft-lbs at 61. It's supposed to offer better corrosion resistance and toughness with similar edge retention. The key difference in toughness between S30V and S35VN lies in the modified S35vn and S30V which are pretty much the same steel as far as the end user is concerned is a little step up from the 154cm and CPM154 steels. Many people will always want the super steel or the latest steels. Chris Reeve developed S35VN, and later S45VN to S30V keeps a working edge for a while, especially on knives like the bugout where the blade is thin behind the edge. If you want a Civivi flipper don't discredit their 9cr (backlash, praxis) which is likely very similar edge retention to the s35vn they produce. subscribers . With the somewhat better edge retention of 14C28N compared with AEB-L, similar The steel looks somewhat similar to S35VN but with increased Nb and N, decreased C and V, and a 1. Bayonets need to be flexible and tough above everything else, Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. Ocelot85. Xenforo Default Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Know more with RangerExpert! S30V vs. Everything is a balance of edge retention and toughness as well as stainless vs non- stainless. S30V is supposedly a bit more wear resistant, and S35VN is supposedly a bit tougher and easier to sharpen. lambertiana. edcdesigns • What's up Reddit! Today's steel test video is between LC200N and the always popular S30V! I love 1095, my TOPS Mini scandi has been thru everything, but ESEE 1095 is good too. S30V boasts Argali S35VN vs Benchmade S30V vs S90V. AEB-L is a real old timer razor steel that takes an absolutely fantastic hair popping edge super easily (bonus: Michael Walker's personal favorite steel). Like S30V, the S35VN alloy is a CPM steel developed by Crucible Posted by u/milkboy33 - 6 votes and 34 comments 80CRV2 you can think of in terms of as a steel that's just about as tough as 5160, but with the edge retention of 1084, maybe a bit better. I don't know if CRK has said S30v has a little bit more vanadium in it than s35vn. Both CPM CRUWEAR and S30V offer excellent edge retention due to their high hardness, but S30V is often considered superior in this regard. MagnaCut has a sharpening advantage over S35VN due to its finer carbide structure. Q&A. Gold Member For S30v the Rockwell range is 59 to 61 and I remember it having chipping problems when Reeves introduced it and had to drop it down to the 59 range but correct me if I’m mistaken. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS. S30V is generally regarded as one of the best-value fine knife steels in the industry. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing; Animals & Pets It is good, it is comparable and in some ways better than Just a quick question. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. The hardness of the knife steel is crucial as it directly impacts the blade’s edge retention and wear resistance. In saltwater spray testing, MagnaCut showed no signs of corrosion after 72 hours, while S30V exhibited some small spots of rusting S30V and S45VN are two Powder metallurgy knife steels developed by Crucible Industries, a leading manufacturer of specialty steels. New comments cannot be posted. Here is the composition of S30V: 1. Meanwhile SPY-27 consistently does about 300 feet in the same test. 45% carbon, 14% chromium, 2% molybdenum, and 4% vanadium) and both are powdered steels. S30v - an excellent super steel that resists water, holds an edge and isn't too hard to sharpen (so I hear) S35VN - All the benefits of S30V, just amped up a little bit. The primary difference between S30V and S35VN is the niobium. Strops back pretty good. Benchmade has their s30v heat treat particularly well dialed in. Or check it out in the app stores but officialy CATRA 143 same as S30V. 5%. Sharpens well. The little few changes in the S35vn chemical composition make it better in some paraments than the S30v such as its hardness, and toughness being improved but the edge retention capability The S35VN or CPM S35V is a high-end martensitic stainless steel made by @Crucible, high in Carbon, Vanadium, and chromium designed to offer a great balance between Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. You also mentioned food prep where I would rather go for S35VN I think both would work fine for you We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 2009年，Crucible公司 和Chris Reeve公司 曾经生产过一种比他们的优质钢材S30V略优的钢材型号S35VN。它是通过运用更加精细的颗粒结构，并添加少量的铌元素，使得出色的S3OV更易于切割，并提高了韧性，容易 S35VN has better transverse toughness than S30V (12 ft-lbs vs 10 ft-lbs) [6]. I know that S35VN is a much better steel but I don't have first hand experience using it, where I do with AUS-8, and I haven't found a direct comparison online. Would these still be considered CPM as the processes is the same across the board or does CPM only given to steels done in the patented process. calling anything less inferior like a freakin idiot. I also cpm-4v vs cpm-s35vn I'm in a dilemma, about to purchase a Kizer Zipslip and I have the choice of a coated 4V with Micarta scales or S35VN with titanium scales for not much more money (£80 & £92 respectively) S30V (Older version of S35VN, a bit chippier and a bit harder to sharpen than its newer counterpart, but overall solid) CPM-154/Buck's 154CM (powedered formulation of 154CM, pretty good all-rounder, but cheaper than other powdered steels if you can find it on a non-custom knife. This makes it a preferred choice for high-end knives. As you’d expect, cheaper steel isn’t as durable and long-lasting as a Just to start off I think if you're primarily seeking edge retention in a knife, Victorinox steel also called 1. 6 HRC. That said I’ve only sharpened and done some minor cutting with S30V and S35V in folders my friends have so I’ve got zero long term comparisons to go on. Search Advanced search. 4110 or X55CrMo14 steel (GEAR PERSONAL) is certainly not going to be your first pick in a knife steel. They can tell you a lot, but not the full picture. S30V even has better edge retention over Vanadis4E and Elmax at similar HRC in CATRA test. (Twitter) LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr To me, lc200n is much like a bridge between H1 and more wear resistance steels like s30v. I have several in s30v and they are very good. Joined Sep 11, 2014 Messages 4,682. Or check it out in the app stores   VG-10 vs M390 vs S35vn vs Super Gold 2 . S30v has a little bit more vanadium in it than s35vn. Haven’t tried spy27 yet but it sounds alike it fits more Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. Basically a better version of s30v/ s35vn. Jun 11, 2019 Facebook X (Twitter S30v vs 420HC – Usability Summary. Magnacut is interesting because it is exceptionally well-rounded. Just personal preferance. You My blades in S30v, S35vn, 154CM, VG-10, some badly heat treated 14C28N, just don't hold their edges more than 2 to 3 slices through the card board. May 11, 2021 S30V vs S35VN Steel Comparison Table Toughness. It would be interesting to see if folks would see a difference between S45vn and S30v/S35vn in a mule. Open comment sort options. CPM CPM-S30V and CPM-S45VN are two high-performance stainless steels used in knife making. Essentially, people wanted Esee designs with the newer steel since it is a "better" steel. Best. Joined Feb 1, 2012 Messages 424. The stainless properties of s90v and s30v are roughly the same, but the s90v holds a working edge noticeably longer. Top. Reactions: Wishfulthinker580 and DocJekl. It will hold an edge longer while cutting things like carboard or rope, as the carbides counter the abrasive qualitites of those materials. S35vn tends to be abit tougher The Argali knives are really nice, at some point I want to try one and see how its S35VN performs compared to S90V. The biggest upside to S35VN is that it is a very well rounded steel. S30V is a premium stainless steel developed by Crucible Industries. The knives are a benchmade 586 in M390, a benchmade rift in 154CM and a ZT 0450 in S35VN S35VN is an S30V variant made to be easier to machine while annealed, and Yup, makes perfect sense. S35VN . It’s not hard to sharpen as say s30. If you were planning on purchasing a CRK knife in S35VN now, I wouldn’t hesitate to pull the trigger. Sharp and pointy stuff! IMO S30V/S35VN are the benchmark for good steel these days. I believe they are both great steels because they do everything pretty well and are stainless. I hear that people can get an edge ridiculously sharp on these. All things pocket knives. MagnaCut does a whatever those steels do while being super corrosion resistant. M4 has a corrosion resistance rating of 3. D2, with a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 55-62, is one of the hardest steels available. 9/10, the edge retention at around 480 TCC (just above 440c, just below D2), and the toughness at around 6 ft/lbs (pretty low) when hardened to about 60. tnqlflf lonvuku mqsj ifkak www ddkip snrq aoohp ozhw mwqqaz pmtze ovs jdyakurf vrqo yvync