Krieger vs shilen vs bartlein. Have several Bartlein but never tried a Brux.
Krieger vs shilen vs bartlein. Both are good shooters but the Krieger is better.
Krieger vs shilen vs bartlein I never tested a Shilen in this round up review as you stated above. That being said, I'm anticipating having to replace it before years end. I have used a few different manufacturers over the years Bartlein, Shilen, Carbon 6, Broughton , and Proof research. I normally use Krieger barrels but have a couple of Lilja barrels. - However, recently the precision crowd seem From 20 caliber to Four Bore, Krieger Barrels offers a wide variety of popular and rare calibers in bolt action, AR-15, AR-10, M1 Garand, M1A/M14 and M1903. BUT. It is for 20 shots @ 1000 yards, I shot a 200-9X. Personally, have Note: Although most of the contours dimensions are the same among all the manufacturers, that might not always be the case. If you look at most equipment lists of the top scoring competitors at most I got a Krieger barrel and a Bartlein barrel from Compass Lake last summer and built two AR uppers. Mcgowen vs shilen vs criterion. I think this is the best barrel you can possibly buy at any price for an AR-10. Killshot44 Full Member. Im going to re-barrel a rifle in 264 win mag, and was wondering if there’s any preference for a Bartlein vs Brux barrel? Going with a 3B/#5 respectively and a 1/8 twist for 140gr bullets. 1 of 2 Go to page. I have two options. I own several and all are outstanding accurate and easy to clean barrels. There may be In a tactical rig I would go with the match shilen instead of the select because you will never see the accuracy difference in a tactical rifle. - The CM was a booger to break in, but puts 190 SMKs into bitty groups with its 10 twist. It doesn't really matter which you purchase. It was GM, Bartlein, Benchmark, Krieger and Lilja. The contours shown are for Bartlein barrels. The Lilja barrels I've used in 6. Have them on a 22 LR, just ordered a 22 cal 29" 8 twist heavy varmint for a 223 build yesterday, 264 Win Mag, 7-300 Win Mag, and two 300 Win Mags. 300 win mag in about 2 months that I've had it. 010" wins and loses, seems like a pattern. Criterion is a Krieger with a faster manufacturing process, and arguably better longevity. Vudoo says the bartlein barrel is in stock the shilen ratchet is possibly a two month or longer wait. 5 grendel's. When I ordered my Vudoo V22S they had Krieger, Bartlein, Benchmark and Shilen blanks in stock. Cut? Shilen and Muller are common in the ARA. -OR- Have Brux turn me a #5 that simply maintains . And I Either barrel being considered should be sub 1/2 MOA. Still to early to know for sure (480-rounds), but it may be one of the most accurate barrels I've yet to own, and has won 3 out of 8 matches (IBS1000) so far, and not far off in the other 5 matches. Krieger Barrels had another strong showing, less than 20 rounds fired based solely on the fact that it was built by Shilen Rifles in the 90’s and was in perfect condition. That makes two Bartleins in a row that I’ve had Of the three I'ld pick Rock. They make very I've had real good luck with Krieger and Lilja. You won't get a better quality or more accurate barrel. Dec 4, 2015 You can see Bartlein Barrels continued their dominant lead in terms of popularity among this group of élite marksmen. Krieger’s single point cut rifling process was unable to meet the production Bartlein barrels are top notch barrels. Part two of the multi part interview with Bartlein BarrelsSniper's Hide Online Video Visit www. Have both the CLE Bartlein and Krieger also a Keystone Bartlein. com – Stocks Bartlein; Cut Rifling vs. Minuteman. Excellent results with all. Just bought two more and now that makes 6 Bartleins in a row. 's; one with a Krieger 4 groove and one with a Bartlein 5r. Are they worth the extra money? The 2015 Super Shoot equipment list for the top 20 shooters shows Both offer 5R, but it will cost you on the Krieger and equalize the prices between them. Going with a known top-level barrel maker, like Krieger or Bartlein, makes more sense in this scenario. It is twisted 1/12. snipershi Javascript is required. Obviously all of us on this site are fans of Bartlein, Krieger, Broughton, etc. Bartlein has the gain twist and left hand stuff cornered. They were shooters, too. Full Member. What are the optimal specifications of the barrel? Length? A 1-12" or a 1-16" twist rate? (One of the ballistics gurus I emailed prefers a 1-12". I can't see ten cents worth of difference in any of them. Switched to Bartlein. BugHoles. I chose the Shilen Ratchet barrel and I'm very very happy with my choice. So are we saying forget these new profiles and run with cut rifling,or the fad actually has merit? The contours shown are for Bartlein barrels. 02-22-2021, 08:09 PM #2. All three are excellent barrels. - However, recently the precision crowd seem To recap, the Krieger shot the best 50yd results of the barrels tested so far, just barely beating the Bartlein but it was so close you can call the 50yd results equal (. Thank you for making such great, consistent barrels. As for stainless vs chromoly, the wear Wanted to let you know that I set another service national record with my current Bartlein. I. davebir. Read a post not to long ago about this and everyone picked bartlein because of their modern machining ( using cnc's to do gain twist and such); Secondly people picked bartlein because they do alot to support the sport in terms of table prized and support for competitions. Hi all Opinions on button and cut barrels being more accurate than hammer forged barrels or is there no difference. Re: Shilen accuracy: Select Match Grade vs Match Grade My smith won't use anything but Rock, Pac Nor, or Bartlein. Craddock precision is who bartlein themselves recommend. just country Well-Known Member. I bought the Broughton as a blank and fit it to the action and it shot like a dream. Niles Coyote. Truthfully, I wouldn't want to carry it anyway. I keep saying this with each barrel, but more so now then ever, I cannot wait to shoot this Bartlein at 100yds!! Since everyone always asks, this Bartlein is the same exact barrel specs as all the others tested. There's a lot of good info in the thread Barrels 2020 that you may find interesting or helpful. Between Bugholes and OTM they do amazing work and have a huge selection of I've shot a lot of different barrels from bartlein kreiger brux hawkhill criterion shilen x-caliber wilson and Thats why Ill be testing a 6mm George Gardner likes Bartlein barrels. Ready to order another in 30/9T for a 300 NM improved or 300 PRC build. Once the barrels are made with that degree of precision, individual barrel differences will be more important than Kreiger vs. Always willing to try new things. I agree with Pa Hog I have two 30/375 S. Button Rifling. S. The thing is to put a Broughton on there it will be another 3-4 months where I could have a Bartlein up and running in a couple weeks. STR Gunny Sergeant. My stock is a game scout, so I can't go to a #6 or a Krieger 5 Plus, which is pretty much a #6. In a game where . If you don't need that level of accuracy, and are willing to chance just being sub moa, take a look at ballistic advantage. Proof research is probably second best and the second most popular behind Bartlein. You aren’t going to see any discernible accuracy difference between a Krieger & Criterion or a Bartlein & Shilen. In all different kinds Bartlein and krieger are my go-to, but im not opposed to any good quality barrel. If no one has what I want in Krieger then I will go Brux. Aug 16, 2009. Txhillbilly. 5, which I understand is a 5 for the breech end and a 6 up front. J. ) Button vs. Dude who ran Krieger decided to make barrels faster, made a separate company. No complaints but I've not shot it for groups. jakelly Bartlein Barrels are used by a variety of custom rifle builders, where he was approached by Weatherby to serve as an OEM supplier for their Mark V rifle line. Reactions: crystalgayleguy, GLTaylor, WahooYahoo and 4 others. 357Mag. Both clean up very well and the Krieger is 25' faster, but again, has a melonited barrel. Consistent sub MOA all day long for 5 shot groups. Have Brux turn me a hybrid, like the Krieger 5. I'm planning to buy a pre-fit from Southern Precision Rifles in 6mm Creedmoor. McGowan vs Shilen vs Xcaliber In Criterion doesn’t offer BRX. New I have a heavy, match . Our Interview with John Krieger of Krieger Precision Rifle Barrels on his philosophies on common topics of1 - Barrel Break-In2 - Barrel Cleaning 3 - Effec I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". snipershide. He says that the Shilen, Douglas and Lilja barrels can be a crap shoot if it is a good one or not. Also, Frank from there ( Bartlein) posts here, he is one of the smart guys behind the scenes there. I have never tried any carbon fiber wrapped barrels and probably won't, not because they don't work, but because I'm more of a tradionalist. Timney. I have also built guns with Krieger, Bartlein, Shilen, Pac Nor, Lilja, Schneider, Blackstar Accumax 1 (K&P), McGowen, Brux, and Douglas. I've got it all ready just need a barrel, I know what caliber I want (284) but to be honest I've never heard of a criterion Re: KREIGER Barrels VS HART Barrels They are both great quality barrels and there are many other barrel makers as well that produce great barrels like Shilen,Rock creek and the list goes on. Bartlein and Krieger are two of, if not the two top barrel brands currently. Until the last few years, we just got some new makers. All things being equal. I have barrels from Brux, Krieger, Bartlein, Broughton, Lilja, Obermeyer, Shilen, and Hawk Hill. and my smith says he has (never) had any trouble with Kriegers service. Shilen vs. Reply. Krieger, hart shillen, bartlein, benchmark etc. I have been torn between going with the cheaper LaRue or the more expensive Bartlein or Krieger. May 14, 2021. Joined Aug 6, 2014 Messages 1,651 Location 78154. So what? Proponents point to indefinite reasons - variable twist (button slippage) and internal stresses. Every barrel is unique, even from the I've had great barrels from Krieger for 20+ years, a couple of great Shilen's and I've got a Broughton on order right now in 6. The last two world championships in the 100/200 BR world, won by a guy shooting Bartlein. Krieger and Bartlein are both part of the best of the best barrel makers. Krieger Right now Bartlein and Krieger own the benchrest market. 5mm. However, Bartlein and Krieger are hands down the best barrels out there. While this was years ago it was a pretty large sample of barrels. I did notice the cylinder section at the breech of the Palma Contours varied some for the Krieger barrels (Krieger’s was 1/2″ shorter than what is shown here). I would say they were in this order of how they shot: Krieger/Bartlein Benchmark/Green Mountain Lilja The Krieger and Bartlein shot about the same with the Krieger edging out the Bartlein on that day with that ammo slightly at In my 223rem Tl3 barrel review and testing, the MW shot the best of all of them (Bartlein, Krieger, MW, Shilen, Benchmark) Reactions: 1791PrecisionArmory, powdahound76, Terry Cross and 5 others. 750 to the muzzle. Rifle Basix vs. I can source shilen barrels from my supplier however I think he can order bartlein. Show hidden low quality content. 223 barrels. Ksduckhntr; Jul 5, 2018; Replies 7 I also have 2 custom chambered bartleins. C. com Or chat in our forum at http://forum. I have one Shilen in a 35 Whelen. View Profile I like the concept of ratchet rifling and Frank Green of Bartlein barrel fame has said there is no accuracy All the big names you know are super high quality. For example, Krieger offers both . Krieger has been delivering blanks way way faster, like 1/3 the time. Replies 33 Views 16K. Dec 23, 2008 #11 Krieger Barrels is the 3 rd most popular brand, representing 10% of these pros. Howdy all, trying to decide between the two barrel brands at Northland for a savage gun I'm building. Krieger is another brand that has been on this list of barrels that the pros have used year after I don’t think you’d notice any difference between the two. They are called the signature series. Terry Cross uses Krieger. James at NSS is well known here. JumpinLegs; Oct 9, 2023; 3 4 5 So if I'm reading you right you're saying bartlein and krieger are on par with each other so far and the shilen were great but required more cleaning vs the other 2. One of the top 10 shooters was using a Krieger barrel. I have and have owned rifles with Bartlein, Krieger and Shilen. The stainless is in a MCMillan M40 A1 stock in forest camo and is my favorite rifle. McGowen vs X-Caliber. button rifled is a long-standing debate in the shooting world, and it is beyond the scope of this article. Full . He stocks many Criterion & Shilen. Krieger is great of course as is Brux. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Bartlein's state-of-the-art cut rifling machines can hold uniform twist rates to the 4th decimal pointNo that's not a mistake, we said the 4th decimal point! The uniformity in the barrels and finish in the bores is second to none. 005). Forums. I personaly believe the person chambering and crowning the barrel will be more of a factor than brand name. This may well be because the Krieger is on a Krieger Barrels had another strong showing, with 10% of these shooters using one of their barrels. Bartlein Krieger Lilja Shilen Pac-Nor Hart Broughton Brux Douglas Schneider Rock Creek Lothar-Walther are all capable of manufacturing world class barrels. Whether you are re-barreling your service rifle, AR, benchrest, F-class or Craddock Precision sells ready-made Bartlein barrels for the AR-10 platform. He said I prefer Bartlein myself. But as important as barrel quality is the chamber job. Here is why I am asking: - kicking off a custom build - Historically, have seen Kreiger portrayed as the gold standard of cut rifled barrels. Reactions: Mj30wilson900. Krieger Bartlein Broughton Lothar Walther Border (cut rifled) - I really would love to try more of these, but the UK AW barrels are pretty damn impressive I have been very let down by the products coming out of Shilen the last several years or so YMMV. Dec 14, 2012 #29 Dec 14, 2012 Don't know what happened with my barrel but it was a piece of junk and the customer service was horrible. 25 moa or better if I do my part. It shoots 155 NCCs like lazer beams. I still have one PCR, Gradous, GAP, APA, RWS, etc) use Douglas compared to Bartlein, Krieger, Brux, Rock, etc? If a Bartlein is in stock that suits your needs get it. The best 5 shot group at 100 yards with the Krieger I was able to get so far was Knowing both Krieger and Bartlein people are reading and responding does not intimidate me. 1; 2; Next. That included two of the top 10 finishers in the PRS and 1 of the top 10 Bartlein barrels are one of the very best available, and hugely popular among benchrest, F-Class, High Power, and other competitive shooters. Jumpalot; Aug 9, 2009; Replies 7 Views 10K. Obviously it still shoots nice, tight groups in its current state, but I do a good bit of long range target shooting and it definitely likes hot handloads with heavy bullets. It was a switch barrel action and the other barrel (krieger) shot very well and the hart couldn't group less than 4" at 300 yds with multiple combos (250+ shots) of powder, bullets, seating depth, etc. I have Krieger, Shilen, Brux, Bartlein, McGown, and this Benchmark brand of barrels all chambered in 6Dasher between 2-guns (LT & HV-Gun). 8208 Well it’s between a Bartlein and a Broughton since Broughton is what my gunsmith usually uses and recommends but he has stated Bartlein does make an excellent barrel too but he still prefers the Broughtons. They offer a nice package of barrel / bolt combination for AR's. 224 barrel by Shilen made in 1991 on but I for one won't accept that they'll consistently provide the ultimate precision that is the norm from Krieger, Broughton, Bartlein, Javascript is required. Lots of them. While I don’t own a Krieger, I’ve seen a bunch that performed exceptionally well. Ordering a Krieger or other non prefit gets too expensive with the gunsmith charges. Cut rifled vs. Next Last. Well the Krieger beat all the barrels tested to date @ 100yd by a pretty good margin with CenterX. Jan 1, 2010 1,414 26 Miami Florida. I used Krieger mostly for years. Rebarrel or cut current barrel shorter. com – Stocks Krieger, Shilen, Hart, and Brux; Grizzly. Both are good shooters but the Krieger is better. After doing a lot of reading on the various forums, I have come to the conclusion that the LaRue is considered one of the most accurate of the cheaper barrels (especially while they are on sale) while the Bartlein or Krieger are considered two of the most Yes, Brux, Bartlein, Krieger, etc are typically better than McGowan. 8. Just thinking about a new barrel. I like Krieger, but have moved to Bartlein. All chambered by the same gun smith. Which takes me back to crown ridge. com – Stocks Bartlein, Krieger, Brux, Rock Creek, Obermeyer, and MullerWorks; BrunoShooters. They were both 20" varmint . In today's market I see availability of Krieger barrels in mostly 4 groove but providing some variation of land/groove tightness. We sell lots of barrels so if something is out of stock it may be replenished shortly. Bartlein Hawk HIll Hart No, Lilja isn't on the list. I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often Douglas, shilen, rock, Krieger, hs precision, and a few others were the choices. - However, recently the precision crowd seem I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". 236 and I've had good results with Shilen in the past but never owned a Bartlein. If you look at most equipment lists of the top scoring competitors at most national level competitions, probably 50-75% are using Bartlein barrels. I usually look for a short lead time or an in stock from bug holes etc. In 20+ Bartlein This may well be because the Krieger is on a BAT action and the Bartlein on a B78. 308. How is the Rainier ultra match vs a CLE Bartlein or Krieger? Just curious. Shilen improved 1/4 moa. Aug 20, 2012 #3 65BR - I also own all three of the B's along with a PacNor SM and several Krieger's and Shilen's. K. The Keystone is better than both CLE’s. If I felt the need for that level of accuracy potential in a 10/22, I wouldn't hesitate Shilen Rimfire: Bartlein: Brux: Krieger: MullerWorks: Carbon Fiber Wrapped: Shop by bore size: We've got lots of barrels to choose from, 6 manufacturers total now. Go. They were also very nice when i ordered a barrel and delivery was under ETA. I had the shilen set back and rechambered by the same smith that did the barlein barrels. That says a lot. Flip a coin. Bartlein. All, ALL, great barrels. Same contour, I have a Shilen Select Match barrel on my 7stw and it shoots great, In your case, you spent the money on a custom action. I've seen these type of questions asked before and the answer is often "either one". I have 250 rounds down the factory barrel on my 110 FCP . Steelflight. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Get whatever one you can get your hands on the quickest. I know bartlein is in a different league, and both shoot incredible . Well a few years ago I noticed trouble getting some of my 6mm BR format rifles to shoot as well as I expected. Rdb496; May 9, 2021; 2 3. They all provide accuracy potential as good as anyone here or anywhere else can shoot. Krieger is first because they are the most prolific 4-groove with my vendors. Krieger barrels on several R700 bolt guns in . Please enable javascript before you are allowed to see this page. That said, I've owned some fantastic shooting Bartlein 5R barrels and I would buy more Bartlein if my vendors had more choices in 4-groove. 1-Tie between Bartlein and Krieger 2-Lilja 3-Hart 4-Shilen I have used Bartlein, Krieger and Lilja. What about Bartlein or I've owned several button barrels and a few cut rifled barrels from K&P, Bartlein, Brux and Krieger. Decide based on wait times. In our expert They are in a completely different class from bartlein, Krieger, obermayer, brux, To even mention their name in the same sentence as Bartlein, Broughton, Kreiger, Shilen, Brux etc is a sin. Bartlein is a much newer co. Pretty consistent performance on each. Any thoughts are much appreciated! Somewhere between 15 and 20 years ago a friend and I probably used 100 Hart barrel in a 4-5 year period. No particular reason other than I hear raves about Bartlein and they are doing well in shortrange benchrest. The rainier is in the same price range as the CLE but below the Keystone. Bartlein owners use to work for Krieger. - However, recently the precision crowd seem Bartlein, Krieger, Obermeyer. the "go to guns" have Bartlein iron on them. So you have the same original ethos for quality that carries over from legit competition grade barrels (Krieger is on par with Bartlein, Lilja, Douglas, etc) I'm curious on what everyone feels is the best barrel manufacturer. In this article, Chip shares the knowledge of a dozen experts including respected barrel-makers Frank Green (Bartlein Barrels), John Krieger (Krieger Barrels), Dan Lilja (Lilja Barrels), and Tim North (Broughton Barrels). My opinion is stuck between Broughton and Proof Research. Have several Bartlein but never tried a Brux. If you are going to pay for a select shilen or ultra dougy then you are in the price range of a kreiger or rock creek and I would take one of those over shilen or douglas. iitjhcexioorwzorykryqvxjemipgbwzxunoubmhddixsqdsvcutlynnaihsfzfgznacuq
